McKenzie Exercises for Sciatica: What They Are and Who They Help

McKenzie Exercises for Sciatica: What They Are and Who They Help

The McKenzie method, also called Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT), is a way of assessing back and leg pain by watching how symptoms respond to repeated movements, then choosing exercises to match. It is best known for press-ups, but it is an assessment system and not a single exercise. This post explains the main ideas and what the research shows. For sciatica in general, see the Sciatica and Low-Back Pain page.

The Two Ideas Behind the Method

  • Directional preference: one direction of repeated movement or sustained position that eases your symptoms or frees up your movement. It is often bending backward, and sometimes bending forward or shifting to one side.

  • Centralization: leg pain that retreats toward the spine during those movements, for example from the calf to the thigh to the buttock. The back itself can feel a little sorer for a while as the leg pain eases.

The opposite is called peripheralization: pain that spreads further down the leg. That is a signal to stop that movement.

What the Research Shows

  • A review of 62 studies found that centralization occurred in about 44% of people with back or neck pain, and more often when the pain was recent (74%) than when it was long-standing (42%). About 70% had a directional preference. In 21 of 23 studies that looked at outcomes, people whose pain centralized tended to do better.

  • In a randomized trial that assessed 312 people with low back pain or sciatica, those who showed a directional preference were given exercises that matched it, opposed it or were non-directional. The matched group had faster reductions in pain and in medication use.

  • A more recent review of trials in people with long-standing low back pain and a directional preference found that the McKenzie method, delivered by credentialed therapists, reduced short-term pain by about one point on a ten-point scale compared with other treatments. The authors rated the certainty of this evidence as low.

  • Another review of 14 studies in long-standing low back pain found that results were similar to other physiotherapy approaches, so this is one reasonable option and not the only one.

Most of this research is on low back pain with or without leg pain. Studies of sciatica from a confirmed nerve root problem are fewer.

What the Exercises Look Like

  • Lying face down, then propping up on the elbows.

  • Press-ups: lying face down and pushing the upper body up with the arms while the hips stay down.

  • Standing back bends.

  • For some people the helpful direction is bending forward or shifting the hips to one side instead.

The right direction is found by testing, not guessing. A movement is kept only if your leg symptoms ease or centralize during and after it.

Rules of Thumb If You Try Them

  • Leg pain easing or moving up toward the back: keep going.

  • Leg pain spreading further down the leg, or new numbness, tingling or weakness: stop and get assessed.

  • Small doses repeated through the day are the usual approach. In the trial above, people were asked to do their exercises every two hours.

When Sciatica Needs Urgent Care

Go to an emergency department right away for numbness around the genitals or inner thighs, new trouble passing urine or controlling your bladder or bowels, or weakness in both legs.

See a physician promptly for a foot that drags, leg weakness that is getting worse, or back pain with fever, unexplained weight loss or a history of cancer.

What to Expect

  • An assessment that may include repeated-movement testing to see whether your symptoms have a directional preference, along with neurological testing of the leg.

  • A plan that usually includes one or two exercises to repeat through the day and advice on sitting, bending and activity. Hands-on care may be part of it.

  • A reassessment after a short course of care.

  • Not everyone improves. If you are not improving at the reassessment, the plan is changed or you are referred on.

Book an Assessment in NW Calgary

Dr. Lau will assess your back and leg symptoms first and let you know what is likely to help. Dr. Michael Lau, Calgary Chiropractor, 3604 52 Ave NW #138, Calgary, AB T2L 1V9. Call (403) 282-4004 or book online. Related reading: The McGill Big 3: Core Exercises for Low Back Pain and the Sciatica and Low-Back Pain page.

Sources

Previous
Previous

Desk and Home-Office Setup: A Practical Guide for Neck and Back Comfort

Next
Next

Text Neck and Posture: Does Bad Posture Cause Neck Pain?